Why MultiCare Hospital replaced Data Domain De-Dupe with SEPATON - February 1, 2009
Orlando Florida -- The S2100-ES2, first installed a little more than a year ago, fit the bill. The Fibre Channel (FC) appliance has a VTL interface, making it faster than the NAS/iSCSI-based products many smaller businesses have come to favor for disk-based backup. The clustered device can scale nondisruptively from one to 32 hardware nodes, which helps MultiCare keep up with data growth.
Zuspan says MultiCare also evaluated a comparable product from Diligent Technologies Corp. before it was bought by IBM Corp., but wanted a pre-assembled appliance rather than having to provide hardware to go with Diligent's software. In addition to potentially complicating support, Zuspan says the Diligent software made it difficult at that time to provision underlying storage hardware using MultiCare's IBM SAN Volume Controller (SVC) storage virtualization appliance.
Meanwhile, the Windows team at MultiCare had deployed Data Domain's DD460 and DD560 deduplicating disk arrays for disk-based backup. Data Domain is the most widely deployed data deduplication product with approximately 2,500 installations. Like most Data Domain customers, MultiCare's Windows division was using Data Domain's inline data deduplication with a NAS interface and Ethernet connectivity.
Data Domain doesn't yet offer data deduplication across multiple nodes, although company officials say it's on the roadmap in 2010. In the meantime, MultiCare's Windows team ran up against the capacity limits of first one and then a second Data Domain box last year, and started writing to the Sepaton VTL instead. Given the slower Ethernet interfaces and inline approach to dedupe on the Data Domain box, Zuspan says "performance was pretty limited" for the Windows team as well. A typical Windows backup that had taken four and a half hours with Data Domain took an hour and 20 minutes with Sepaton. Zuspan says his company's Windows team still uses Data Domain, but may phase out its arrays over time.
The Windows team actually used Sepaton's DeltaStor data deduplication before Zuspan's Unix team. That's because Sepaton's "application-aware" deduplication must be certified separately with each backup vendor it wants to work with, while Data Domain and other vendors offer the same deduplication regardless of backup software. The Windows team was using Symantec Corp.'s Veritas NetBackup, the first backup application certified with DeltaStor. The Unix team used Hewlett-Packard (HP) Co.'s Data Protector backup software; however, Sepaton didn't support Data Protector until late last year. This is exactly the reason Data Domain has lost 47% of it's marketshare in the last few years.
But Zuspan says Sepaton's deduplication was worth the wait. "[Because] it's application-aware, it can see by the signature of data that it's, say, Exchange email, and then runs an algorithm based on that," he says. This leads to "huge" deduplication ratios for applications like Exchange, where Zuspan says the S2100-ES2 is currently storing 619 logical GB in 6.18 GB of physical space—a 100:1 data-reduction ratio. The overall 200 TB backup, which includes files such as radiology images that can't be deduped, is stored on 75 physical TBs.
Sepaton's deduplication is also post-process, which some observers say makes it difficult to meet backup windows to offsite media through replication or copies to tape. But Zuspan points out another unique Sepaton dedupe feature called "forward differencing," which stores the most recent backup while deleting redundant data from older backup sets. This makes short-term restores and copies to tape easier, he notes, because the most recent full backup is stored quickly and intact.
For more information please call (407) 265-6293 or visit us at: http://www.sencilo.com/storage-data-deduplication.php
About Us
Sencilo Solutions is a Florida-based integrator specializing in Cost Cutting storage, security and managed services solutions. Sencilo delivers a comprehensive portfolio of products from best-of-breed hardware and software from multiple manufacturers including VMware, Data Domain, EMC, Hitachi, Symantec, HDS, IBM, Commvault, Xiotech and HP. Its technical expertise is known throughout the storage and security industry. Clients include leading corporations, major financial institutions, top universities, government facilities, as well as small to medium size businesses. Sencilo's professional services include consulting, integration, project management, storage virtualization installation, maintenance and knowledge transfer.
Sencilo has offices throughout Florida including: Jacksonville, Daytona Beach, Tampa, St. Petersburg, Orlando, Hialeah, St. Augustine, Gainesville, Ocala, Palm Coast, Clearwater, Kissimmee, Lakeland, Maitland and Cape Canaveral Green Simpana Offerings Projects: BC DR planning Replication De-Dup De-Dupe iSCSI SAN NAS VMware Security EMC NetApp HP IBM Quantum Compliance VTL Data Domain vs Gartner Magic Quadrant Quadrent LTO Backup Exc Pure Disk NetBackup Networker TSM Commvault BakBone D2D D2D2T compare cloud data deduplication thin provisioning DXi Global Compression DDX virtual tape library Data Reduction SEPATON FALCON compare Celerra CLARiiON Equallogic Dell NS20 NS40 CX4 CX3-20 CX3-40 CX3-80 FAS2050 FAS3050 Xiotech Nexsan Avamar DLD3 1500 D3 Storwiz storage compression data Ocarina Networks A-SIS compare Sepaton infopro BlueArc OnStor Microsoft Unified Storage data protection StorageX Brocade FAQ SSD Solid state disk SANmelody FalconStor tier zero Xiotech ISE nx4 ax4 greenBytes ZFS Sun Top 10 ROBOBak managed services hosting cloud grid Datacore Compellent compellant equallogic lefthand networks don't buy storage stop buying storage itguardian cherub networks Arkeia Network Backup appliance Data Recovery Backup Health IT Healthcare IT Digital Hospital Allscripts
